What Is the Jersey Mike’s “Pregnancy Sub”?

It’s not an official menu item. It’s a nickname that caught on after pregnant customers kept ordering the same combo and posting about it online. The build is the #1 BLT, made Mike’s Way, piled with extra pickles, banana peppers, and a scoop of pepper relish, usually on Rosemary Parmesan bread. Some people swap in provolone or go heavier on the mayo. There’s no secret code to memorize; just describe it to whoever’s building your sandwich.

Is It Actually Safe to Eat at Jersey Mike’s While Pregnant?

Yes. The one thing to watch is cold, sliced deli meat, because of a small Listeria risk. Pregnancy changes how your immune system responds, which is why the CDC and ACOG both recommend heating deli meat until it’s steaming, around 165°F, before eating it. That guidance has nothing to do with Jersey Mike’s specifically. It’s the same advice for any deli counter, grocery store, or sandwich shop. And since most of the menu can be grilled or heated on request, working around it is easy.

Menu Items: Pregnancy Safety at a Glance

Menu Item	Pregnancy Safety	What to Know
#1 BLT	Safe	Bacon is cooked crispy, not cold cut
Hot Subs (Philly, cheesesteaks)	Safe	Meat is grilled at high heat
Cold cut subs (turkey, ham, salami, Italian)	Needs a tweak	Ask staff to heat the meat until steaming
Tuna sub	Mostly safe	Canned light tuna; watch weekly mercury intake
Veggie sub	Safe	No meat concerns
Provolone, American, Swiss	Safe	Pasteurized hard cheeses
Sub in a Tub (no bread)	The same meat rule applies	Ask for heating if it’s a cold cut

Is the BLT (the “Pregnancy Sub”) Really Safe?

Yes, and that’s exactly why it became the unofficial pregnancy sub in the first place. Bacon is cooked hot and crispy, not sliced cold from a deli case, so the usual Listeria concern simply doesn’t apply the way it does with turkey or ham. The lettuce, tomato, and in-store mayo are all fine as-is. As long as the bacon comes out fully cooked, which is standard, this is a genuinely solid order.

Can You Eat Jersey Mike’s Turkey While Pregnant?

You can, just not straight off the cold slicer. Turkey & Provolone uses freshly sliced deli turkey that hasn’t been reheated, so ask the crew to grill it or heat it until steaming before it lands on your bread. Most stores can do this without missing a beat, since the flat-top grill is already fired up for hot subs. Would rather not request at all? Mike’s Chicken Philly or a grilled cheesesteak gets you a similar flavor with no extra step.

Can You Eat Jersey Mike’s Turkey While Pregnant?

It’s fine in moderation. Jersey Mike’s uses canned light tuna, which runs lower in mercury than tuna steak or albacore, and the FDA allows two to three servings of canned light tuna a week during pregnancy. The thing to actually track is your total weekly mercury intake, so skip it if you’ve already had salmon or another fish that week. Because it’s a mayo-based salad rather than sliced deli meat, it doesn’t carry the same Listeria concern; just eat it fresh rather than let it sit out.

What About Calories in the Pregnancy Sub?

The base #1 BLT comes in at 710 calories, 20g protein, 59g carbs, 44g fat, and 1,618mg sodium on regular bread, per Jersey Mike’s own nutrition data. The viral pregnancy sub runs higher than that because of the added pickles, banana peppers, pepper relish, and the switch to Rosemary Parmesan bread. Since it’s a custom order, the real number depends on your store and your exact build, so the Jersey Mike’s app will give you the most accurate total for what you actually order.

Should You Worry About Listeria at Jersey Mike’s?

There’s no confirmed Listeria outbreak tied specifically to Jersey Mike’s. What people are really reacting to is a broader issue: deli meat as a category carries a small Listeria risk for anyone, and that risk matters more during pregnancy because of how your immune system shifts. If you’ve eaten cold deli meat and later develop a fever, unusual fatigue, or muscle aches within a few weeks, mention it to your doctor. Symptoms tend to be mild and flu-like, but it’s worth the quick call rather than waiting it out.

Is Jersey Mike’s Tuna Okay During Pregnancy?

This is the part most guides skip: what actually to say if your go-to order is a cold sub.

If You Usually Order	Pregnancy-Safe Move
#7 Turkey & Provolone	Ask for the turkey grilled, or order it as a hot sub
#13 The Original Italian	Request all deli meats heated until steaming
#3 Ham & Provolone	Ask for the ham grilled, or try the Chicken Philly instead
#8 Club Sub	Ask for the turkey and ham heated (the bacon is already safe)
#6 Roast Beef & Provolone	Ask for the roast beef heated until steaming
#10 Tuna Fish	No changes needed, just keep it to a couple of servings a week

How to Order a Pregnancy-Safe Sub (In One Sentence)

Whatever you’re ordering, this one line covers you:

Beyond that:

• ✅ Stick to Hot Subs if you’d rather not request at all
• ✅ The BLT is a safe default (the bacon is already cooked)
• ✅ Provolone, American, and Swiss are pasteurized and fine as-is
• ⚠️ Limit tuna to a couple of servings a week
• ✅ Order fresh, not pre-made or sitting out
• 💡 Most crews have heard this request before and won’t blink at it

Jersey Mike’s APP Conclusion!!

You don’t have to skip your Jersey Mike’s craving just because you’re pregnant. The viral pregnancy sub earned its name for a real reason. It’s built around cooked bacon rather than cold deli meat, which makes it one of the safer orders on the menu. For everything else, one sentence at the counter is all it takes. For a full calorie and protein breakdown, check our Jersey Mike’s nutrition guide, or head back to the full Jersey Mike’s menu to plan your next order.

Testimonials